Local Interactive Strategies

Too much to sell!

Let me get this straight.

Toyota comes out with a new model and the salespeople say “Stop! I’ve got too much to sell!”

Apple comes out with a new iPod and the salespeople say “You don’t seriously expect me to sell one more product, do you?”

Guitar Hero 3 comes out and there’s a near-riot at the sales meeting where it’s announced. “We can’t sell what we have right now!” says one frazzled sales rep.

Sound nuts? Listen up: those are direct quotes I’ve heard over the years from newspaper sales people in markets large and small. Worse: I’ve heard those same things from newspaper sales managers.

And here’s the really crazy part. As an industry, those responses are not only routine, they are often accepted as normal and maybe even reasonable.

Those behaviors — and the culture that breeds them — underline a fundamental problem facing the newspaper industry. The entire sales process is focused on selling products, not solutions.

Selling solutions is what happens when you’re in the market for a car and you stop by the Toyota dealer. The salesperson (if he/she is any good) starts by understanding your needs and then helping you select a vehicle and options that meet your needs. Ideally that results in you getting the car you want, and the salesperson getting a sale. If the salesperson is really good, you’ll discover needs you didn’t even think you had (built-in GPS to avoid getting lost all the time!) and you’ll happily spend more.

The Toyota salesperson doesn’t start by presenting you a list of all the possible models and all the possible options, and then trying to sell you the vehicle and options that maximize the price you’ll pay. Or maybe he does, but do you stick around?

Contrast this with the typical newspaper sales rep’s environment: there’s always a new program to sell, monthly goals to hit on specific products, another one-sheet at the sales meeting to help fill the next special section. And now here comes “online” — geez, one more thing to sell.

Successful products are developed — and sold — as   solutions to   unmet customer needs. A customer-centric, solutions-based sales process brings customer needs forward, guides development of new products around those needs, and then presents the products to customers as solutions to their needs.

How far is the typical newspaper sales operation from that model? What will it take to turn that operation into one that eagerly anticipates the next new product?

Step one is to start listening, really listening. I’m convinced some of the current problems are partly the result of years of not listening to customers.


  • Customers complain prices are too high,  yet the solution is to work harder at selling value, rather than developing lower-cost products. By not listening, we create an opportunity for competitors to launch products that meet those needs. Anyone seen that happen?
  • Online as a value-add, or forced upsell. Some customers will truly benefit from an online program; others won’t benefit at all. A forced upsell means the customers who value online advertising never get the opportunity to talk about their needs and describe online’s role. And those who don’t need or want online advertising aren’t listened to, but forced to buy it anyway. Will either of those advertisers ever look to the newspaper as a valued partner for online advertising?
  • Pricing models that don’t line up with customers’ valuations. In starting online from scratch in the 1990s, we had no pricing models to work from. We had to work with potential customers to establish the value. Certainly we had limits on how flexible we’d be, but it was almost an auction environment until certain valuations began to gel around basic and premium pricing. Contrast that with a typical newspaper, where an ad in the Sports section (where no one seems to want to be) costs the same as an ad in the A section (where everyone wants to be). The market is speaking, but we’re not listening.

These examples don’t reflect poor values. They often come from a sense of fairness to customers, or a desire to deliver the highest value to customers. What they don’t reflect is a culture of listening and responding to customers.

What do you think? What will it take to get to where a new newspaper product generates the same sales excitement as a new iPod?

February 16, 2008 - Posted by | Uncategorized

1 Comment »

  1. What will it take to get to where a new newspaper product generates the same sales excitement as a new iPod?

    Will never happen Joe…maybe 4 years ago the newspapers would have created some excitement with New Media but not now and not with current stable of newspaper reps in most markets..too slow to change, too slow to learn. Start hiring new media reps and teach them how to sell print.

    Never ever say “value add” when talking about online, those days are over! Online should be targeting 40% of advertisers print budgets and giving customers a good ROI. How? Development, solid technical infrastructure, verticals, interactivity with users.
    Cars, Real Estate, Jobs, RV’s, Travel, Text Alerts, Breaking News, Weather, Tourism, and more…
    Google is taking over the web world so newspaper sites better make their moves fast or whammo! It’s all over..

    Comment by Flip | February 25, 2008 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: